The Five-Star Weekend, now streaming on Peacock, has captivated audiences with its enchanting portrayal of Nantucket and its compelling storylines. Based on Elin Hilderbrand’s 2026 novel, the series follows food influencer Hollis Shaw, played by Jennifer Garner, as she navigates grief and reconnects with friends during a weekend getaway. The show’s stunning visuals and engaging narrative have left viewers eager for more.
The series has sparked curiosity about its future, with fans hoping for a second season. While Peacock has yet to officially renew the show, there are several factors that could influence its decision.
The Potential for a Second Season
The Five-Star Weekend was initially conceived as a limited series, adapting the entirety of Hilderbrand’s novel. However, the show’s popularity and the open-ended nature of its storylines have left the door open for a continuation. Hilderbrand herself has been vocal about her desire to see the story unfold further, teasing fans on social media with the possibility of a second season.
Showrunner Bekah Brunstetter has also hinted at having ideas for a potential second season, suggesting that the women’s friendships and new dynamics could be explored. The cast has floated intriguing plot twists, such as a getaway to Greece and further developments in the characters’ lives.
Cast and Character Dynamics
The series boasts a stellar cast, including Regina Hall as Dru-Ann, Chloë Sevigny as Tatum, D’Arcy Carden as Brooke, and Gemma Chan as Gigi. The ensemble’s chemistry and the richly drawn characters have been praised by critics and audiences alike. The potential return of supporting characters, such as Judy Greer as Electra and Timothy Olyphant as Jack, has also generated excitement.
Nantucket: A Character in Itself
Nantucket serves as a central character in The Five-Star Weekend, with its picturesque beaches, charming shops, and vibrant community. While most of the series was filmed on a soundstage in Los Angeles, the actual island played a significant role in the production. Hilderbrand, a longtime resident of Nantucket, advocated for filming on the island to capture its unique essence.
The series features real Nantucket locations, such as Bartlett’s Ocean View Farm, CRU Oyster Bar, The Chicken Box roadhouse bar, and Wicked Island Bakery. The cast and crew embraced the island’s amenities during filming, enjoying sailing, dining, and karaoke together. Hilderbrand’s popularity among locals facilitated the production, with businesses eager to support her project.
The Impact on Nantucket
The filming of The Five-Star Weekend has had a mixed impact on Nantucket. While some residents welcomed the production, others expressed concerns about disruption and increased tourism. Hilderbrand hopes that viewers will appreciate the show’s authenticity and recognize the importance of filming on the island.
The Future of The Five-Star Weekend
As of now, a second season of The Five-Star Weekend is not guaranteed, but the show’s success and the enthusiasm of its cast and creators have raised hopes. The series has garnered solid reviews and a dedicated fanbase, with viewers eager to see more of the characters’ journeys. If Peacock takes notice of the show’s popularity, a renewal could be on the horizon.
In the meantime, fans can enjoy the series’ first season, which offers a delightful blend of drama, humor, and scenic beauty. The Five-Star Weekend has not only showcased the allure of Nantucket but also left audiences yearning for more of its captivating storylines and characters.
